Posts Tagged 'scientific methodology'

I Say

One of the things that is almost guaranteed to make me want to set fire to a newspaper is when a story (or worse, a headline) uses the phrase “scientists say”. You can be fairly sure that what follows is going to be spurious, nebulous and any other negative words that end in -ous. However, whilst I do hold papers responsible for crappy reporting as it should be their duty to research their output, I also recognise that there probably is a misconception in the wider public about the “scientists say” myth.

To boil it down, it seems to me that this “scientists say” idea has, at its core, a misunderstanding of how the scientific community gels together and how ideas, experimental data and fundamental concepts all flow around and are interconnected. To be honest, it’s no surprise that people who aren’t scientists don’t just automatically know this. After all, you don’t know how an industry works until you are actually immersed in it yourself.

Continue reading ‘I Say’

Advertisements

This isn’t right. This isn’t even wrong.

The title of this post is a quote from Wolfgang Pauli. It was the ultimate scientific smackdown in response to a terrible paper, which was vague and unfalsifiable.

Based only on Pauli’s quote, let’s then take these 3 statements:

A) Pauli was not supportive of the paper

B) Pauli was supportive of the paper

C) Pauli’s favourite Care Bear would have been TenderHeart Bear, had he not died in 1958.

Of course, A) is right B) is wrong and C) is not even wrong. Essentially, C) isn’t wrong but it certainly isn’t right. It is a disconnected supposition based on… well, nothing. We have no evidence to even begin to test the idea that Pauli would have loved TenderHeart Bear.

Continue reading ‘This isn’t right. This isn’t even wrong.’


Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 6 other followers

Tweets

  • As a guy, does looking at all the #MeToo posts make me feel uncomfortable or embarrassed? It fucking should! We seriously need to do better. 5 days ago
  • "No deal is better than a bad deal" - #TheresaMay No deal IS a bad deal, you fucking jelly. #Brexit 5 days ago
  • Going to buy a family-sized tub of coleslaw in honour of Sean Hughes. 5 days ago
  • Is it true that Sean Hughes has died? If so, very sad. If not... well, good. 5 days ago
  • @helenlewis Seriously, it was great and I love tardigrades more than ever! 1 week ago